Switch course ▾
Session 5. Building a School Observation Culture
Objective. Plan a term of peer observation for a school team, write the protections that keep it separate from appraisal, answer common fears and review whether pupils gained.
Peer observation that depends on one enthusiastic teacher ends when she leaves. A culture is different: it is a habit that colleagues expect and protect. It grows from small kept promises, not from announcements. This lesson goes beyond the key ideas to explain why the first weeks decide the outcome and how to show, without turning observation into inspection, that pupils are gaining from it. It is for any teacher who will be asked 'how do we do this here?' by colleagues or by the head.
Key ideas
Start small and voluntary
- Begin with willing pairs or trios, not the whole staff. A trusted early group makes the practice normal for others to join later.
- A light rhythm works: each member hosts one visit and makes one visit per term, 10 to 15 minutes each. A 'learning visit week' once a term gives a clear date to aim at.
- Never start with the teachers the head worries about. That makes the practice a punishment, and everyone knows it.
Protect it in writing
- A one-page protocol signed by the head: no marks, no notes in any file, visit information is not used for qualification category or pay decisions, and the head's own visits follow the same charter.
- Decide what may be shared: patterns across the school ('pupils speak more in pairs') may be shared; who said what, never.
- Break the protocol once, and trust takes a year to rebuild. Name one person who colleagues can go to if they think it has been broken.
Find the time without extra staff
- Use free periods, swap duties, or let the head or a colleague combine two classes for 15 minutes. Put a 'visit slot' in the timetable so that it is not squeezed out.
- Keep tools on paper in a shared folder: a few tally sheets, a seating chart, a lens card, a charter. A simple log records counts only: visits made, lens used, date.
- The head's most useful job is protecting these 15 minutes when other duties arrive.
Keep it alive and check it works
- At each staff meeting share 'one thing we learned', a pattern without names. Rotate lenses each term so the practice does not feel like the same box to tick.
- Review each term with three questions: did the visits happen, did a pupil-focused count change when we repeated the lens, and did colleagues say they trust it more or less?
- Watch for warning signs: only the same people take part, 'show lessons' appear, or the head asks to read the notes.
From volunteers to habit
Why the first weeks decide
Trust is built from visible, kept promises and broken by one visible exception. If the head says 'no notes in the file' and then asks to see the notes once, the practice is finished in that school. If the head and senior teachers host the first visits, they show that being watched is not a punishment. Colleagues learn the rules by watching what the leaders do, not by reading the protocol.
Plan the first term to be easy to succeed in. Small groups of willing people, one lens, a short slice, a fixed learning visit week and a clear review date make failure unlikely. A quiet success told in one sentence at a staff meeting ('three of us found that pupils talk more in pairs') recruits more volunteers than any announcement.
Checking pupil gain without inspection
Counting visits tells you the practice is happening, not that it helps. A pupil-focused count repeated in the same slice, such as the number of different pupils who speak or the number of questions that wait three seconds, gives a modest but honest signal. Keep the claim small: 'In the 10-minute slice, 5 pupils spoke before and 8 after we changed the task.' Other things also changed, so never say 'proved'.
Share patterns across the team, not figures by teacher. Ask three questions each term: did the visits happen, did the pupil-focused count change, and do colleagues trust the practice more or less? If trust is falling, stop adding visits and repair the cause. A culture that does not check itself drifts into form-filling, and then teachers prepare show lessons again.
Examples from the classroom
The head hosts first
Scene. At a school near Bukhara the head opens the first learning visit week by inviting three colleagues to watch her Grade 5 lesson, with the lens 'who answers?'. The seating chart shows that she calls on the same four pupils. She reads the result aloud at the staff meeting. The next week seven teachers ask to take part.
Insight. Leaders who go first show that being observed is safe and normal.
The teacher with 25 years
Scene. Nigora, with 25 years of experience in Samarkand, says she has nothing to learn from visits. The team asks her to host first, with a lens she chooses: 'Why do my Grade 9 pupils stop writing after 15 minutes?' Two colleagues watch. She finds a pattern in the task order, changes it and becomes the most active host of the term.
Insight. Experienced teachers often have the most to show and a real question of their own.
Counting what changed
Scene. A team of three in Fergana repeats a seating-chart count in November. In October, 6 of 30 pupils spoke in the 10-minute slice; in November, after pair talk was added, 11 spoke. They write a one-page review that says what they changed, what the numbers were, that they cannot be sure the change caused it, and what they will try next.
Insight. A small honest count with its limits stated is stronger than a large claim.
Common pitfalls
- Starting with every teacher at once, so the practice feels like a rule.
- Letting the head read the notes 'just this once'.
- Counting visits and calling that impact.
- Showing figures by teacher at the staff meeting.
Answer the Fears and Plan Your Term
- Open the Activity Kit: eight fear cards teachers might say. In trios, choose four. For each, write a response that changes a rule or a practice, not only a reassurance (15 min).
- Teams from the same school (25 min): fill in the term plan: who takes part, visits per person, the lens for the term, protections in the protocol, where the time comes from, the date of the first learning visit week and the review date.
- Second short activity (20 min): swap plans with another team. They play the sceptic using the remaining fear cards and ask three questions. Revise your plan using what you hear.
- Alone (5 min): write your school-based task from the Kit, including the date on which you will show the plan to your head or team leader.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- Which fear is hardest to answer with a rule change, and why?
- What did the sceptics ask that you had not thought of?
- Who in your school would sign the protocol willingly, and who would you need to convince?
Reflect
- What is the first small step you can take in your school without anyone's permission?
- Who would be your first two partners, and why would they say yes?
- How will you know in a term that pupils, not only teachers, have benefited?
Try it tomorrow
- Ask your head to sign a one-page protocol before the first visit.
- Choose one pupil-focused count to repeat in the same slice after a change.
- Invite a sceptical colleague to host first with a lens she chooses.
Further reading and links
A school observation culture grows from willing pairs, a written protection from appraisal, protected time and a termly check that pupils gain.