Switch course ▾
Session 2. Listening and Questioning: Hearing What Students Mean
Objective. Listen to a student without interrupting, say back what you heard, and ask an open question that gives time to think.
A teacher speaks for much of the day, but the lessons that stay with students often start when the teacher stops and listens. A child who says 'I don't know' may be saying 'I am afraid to be wrong'. A question asked with a pause can bring out thinking that a fast question never reaches. This session gives you simple listening and questioning habits that cost no materials and little time, and that make students more willing to speak.
Key ideas
Listening is a teaching tool
- Students tell you what they find hard only if they feel heard. A rushed 'Fine, sit down' closes the door.
- Active listening has three moves: give full attention (eyes, body turned, pen down), do not interrupt, and say back what you heard.
- Get to the student's level: sit or crouch next to a small child instead of standing over a desk.
Paraphrase and name the feeling
- Say back the meaning in your own words: 'So you did the homework, but the page was torn.' This shows you listened and lets the student correct you.
- Name the feeling, not only the facts: 'It sounds embarrassing when they laugh.' Naming does not mean agreeing with everything.
- Avoid the quick fix and the lecture. First 'I hear you', then, if needed, 'What would help?'.
Questions that open thinking
- A closed question has one short answer ('Is it true?'). An open question needs an explanation ('How do you know?', 'What would happen if ...?').
- Plan two or three key open questions for each lesson, in your plan, instead of making them up at the moment of silence.
- Useful starters: Why, How, What if, What is another way, What makes you think so.
Wait time and fair turns
- After a thinking question, stay quiet for about 3 to 5 seconds. Count silently. Silence is thinking, not failure.
- Ask students to think alone for 20 seconds, then tell a neighbour for one minute, then answer. In a class of 34 this lets many voices be heard.
- After a wrong answer, ask 'What made you think so?' before correcting. Do not take only the first hand: choose also the quiet student, privately agreed beforehand if the student is shy.
Closed and open questions on the same topic
Closed
One short answer
- Is 3/4 bigger than 2/3?
- Is Navruz in March?
- Did you like the story?
Open
Needs an explanation
- How can you show which is bigger?
- What does each Navruz custom mean?
- Which moment stayed with you, and why?
Listening to what is behind the words
Students often say less than they mean. 'I forgot my homework' can mean a sick relative, a shared notebook or a fear of the answer. Listen also for what is missing: a usually talkative child who goes silent, a sudden joke, eyes on the desk. Looking down can be a sign of respect to an elder in many families, so do not read it as defiance or lying.
Choose the place carefully. A private word at the classroom door, while the others pack, often gets more truth than a public question. Keep your own words few. If you say 'Tell me more' and then wait, the student fills the silence with the real concern.
A ladder of questions
Questions have levels. Recall ('What is the capital?'), explain ('Why is it there?'), apply ('Where would you build a new market, and why?') and judge ('Which plan is better?'). Many lessons stay on the first step because recall questions are quick to ask and easy to mark. Plan at least one question from a higher step for each lesson and write it in your plan.
Ask many questions, but make sure all students answer them, not only the confident few. Rosenshine's review of effective teaching recommends asking a large number of questions and checking the responses of all students. Pair talk, mini-whiteboards or paper held up together give you that, even in a class of 34.
Examples from the classroom
'I don't know' at the back
Scene. Aziz teaches Grade 7 geography in Fergana. When he asks Jasur directly, Jasur says 'I don't know'. Instead of calling on someone else, Aziz says, 'No problem. Think about it, I will come back in a minute.' After class he walks Jasur to the door and asks, 'What do you see when you think of the canal near your grandfather's field?' Jasur talks for two minutes.
Insight. A pause and a private, open question turned 'I don't know' into knowledge.
Thinking before answering
Scene. Dilnoza teaches Grade 4 natural science in Samarkand. She asks, 'Why does the puddle disappear in the sun?' Last year she took the first hand. Now she says: 'Think alone for 20 seconds, tell your neighbour for one minute, then I will choose.' She hears five different explanations, including one from a girl who never raised a hand.
Insight. Think-pair-share and a pause bring in quiet students and richer answers.
Listening to a complaint
Scene. Malika teaches Grade 8 in Tashkent. A girl says, 'I don't want to read aloud. Everyone laughs.' Malika puts down her pen, crouches near her and says, 'It sounds embarrassing when they laugh. What would help?' The girl asks to read first in pairs. Malika agrees and also reminds the class how to listen kindly.
Insight. Naming the feeling and asking an open question leads to a workable solution.
Common pitfalls
- Answering your own question after one second of silence.
- Calling on the first raised hand every time.
- Giving advice before the student has finished explaining the problem.
- Repeating the student's words like a parrot without showing you understood the meaning.
Listen, Say Back, Ask
- Form groups of three: speaker, listener, observer. Take one situation card from your Activity Kit (the speaker plays the student and may add details).
- Round 1 (4 min): the listener says nothing except to paraphrase and to name the feeling. The observer ticks the slip. Swap roles; do three rounds in all (about 15 min).
- In pairs (10 min), turn the five closed questions in the kit into open questions and decide the wait time you will use for each.
- Whole group (10 min): read out one new open question and say what you would do after the first answer.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- What was hardest as the listener: not interrupting, not advising or not fixing?
- What did the speaker feel when the listener said back the feeling?
- In which part of your lesson will you leave a 3-second silence this week?
Reflect
- When did a student last tell you something important, and how did you respond?
- Which of your habitual questions have a one-word answer?
- Whom do you rarely hear in your class, and how could you invite them safely?
Try it tomorrow
- Plan two open questions for tomorrow's lesson, including one that starts with 'How' or 'Why'.
- After one thinking question, count silently to five before you say anything.
- Talk privately with one quiet student for two minutes this week and only listen and paraphrase.
Further reading and links
Listen without interrupting, say back what you heard, then ask an open question and wait.