Switch course ▾
Session 1. Why Reflect: From Experience to Learning
Objective. Explain why experience alone does not guarantee learning, and use a five-minute routine and the lenses of courses 5.1-5.9 to reflect on one real lesson.
Every teacher already thinks about lessons, usually late in the evening and usually in the form of a verdict: it went well, it was a disaster. This session shows how to turn that thinking into something that changes the next lesson. You need no special tools, only a notebook and five minutes. By the end you will have looked at one real lesson through three of the lenses you have met in courses 5.1 to 5.9, and chosen a question to carry with you.
Key ideas
Experience is not enough
- Teaching for ten years can mean ten years of learning, or one year repeated ten times.
- What turns experience into learning is a pause, a question and a change.
- Many teachers already reflect on the way home; this course makes it short, structured and useful.
Reflection is not worry or blame
- Worry circles around a lesson without ending; reflection ends with a decision about what to keep and what to change.
- Look at what went well as carefully as at what went wrong. Good moments are evidence too.
- Be as kind to yourself as you would be to a colleague telling you the same story.
Nine lenses from courses 5.1-5.9
- Each earlier course gave you a way of looking at a lesson: learning, planning, management, engagement, assessment, differentiation, communication, digital tools and AI judgement.
- You do not use all nine each time. Choose two or three lenses that fit the lesson.
- A lens gives you a question to ask. The kit lists one question for each.
A five-minute routine you can keep
- Choose one lesson a week. Write for five minutes: what happened, what surprised me, what one thing I will try.
- Use the same notebook every time so you can look back after a month.
- A short note written the same day beats a long one planned for the holidays.
The reflection loop
What makes a good reflection question
A useful question is specific, answerable and about pupils' learning. 'Was I a good teacher today?' is none of these. 'How many pupils could explain the new word in their own words?' is all three, because you can check it with a quick look at their notebooks.
Start questions with 'what', 'when' or 'how many' rather than 'why am I'. They keep you looking at the lesson instead of at yourself. If a question begins to feel like a judgement of you, turn it back into a question about the lesson.
Critical incidents: the moments worth studying
You cannot examine a whole lesson every week, so choose one moment that stood out: a silence that went on too long, a question that suddenly woke the class, a pupil who surprised you. Teacher educators call such a moment a critical incident.
Write it down in four or five sentences as a small scene. Then choose a lens from courses 5.1 to 5.9 and ask what that lens would notice. One well-chosen moment often tells you more than a vague impression of the whole forty-five minutes, and it is small enough to keep you from feeling overwhelmed.
Examples from the classroom
The pencil problem
Scene. Aziz teaches Grade 5 mathematics in Bukhara. After a lesson he notices that the last two rows started the written task five minutes late. His first thought is 'they are slow'. Using the management lens from course 5.3 he asks instead, 'What were they doing at minute 30?' The answer is waiting for pencils. Next week a pupil in each row hands out pencils before the lesson begins.
Insight. Turning a verdict into a question about the lesson found a cause that Aziz could fix in one minute.
A silence that worked
Scene. Malika teaches Grade 7 geography in Fergana. She asks why cotton needs irrigation and nobody speaks for eight seconds. She feels uncomfortable and almost answers herself, but waits. Then a boy explains that his grandfather moves water between the rows. At home she writes the moment as a critical incident and asks, 'What did my waiting make possible?'
Insight. Studying a moment that worked is as valuable as studying one that failed.
Five lines on Friday
Scene. Dilnoza teaches Grade 3 in a Russian-medium school in Tashkent and has always found time for reflection difficult. She now keeps a small notebook and every Friday writes five lines about one lesson: what happened, what surprised her and one thing to try. After six Fridays she reads back and notices the same note in four entries: pupils lose focus at about minute 25.
Insight. A tiny regular routine builds a record from which patterns appear.
Common pitfalls
- Reflecting only on lessons that went badly and ignoring what worked.
- Asking questions about yourself ('Am I good enough?') instead of about the lesson.
- Waiting for a free hour that never comes instead of writing five minutes the same day.
- Writing long notes once a term and never reading them again.
One Lesson Through Three Lenses
- Alone (5 min): in the kit, read the sample lesson memory (Grade 5 mathematics, Bukhara). Then think of a real lesson of your own from this month and note its topic and class.
- Alone (10 min): fill the lens grid for your lesson. Choose three of the nine lenses, write one fact for each and one question it raises. Facts only in the first column.
- In pairs (10 min): tell your partner your lesson in two minutes. The partner asks only 'What did you see?' and 'What do you want to know?'. Swap roles.
- As a group (10 min): each person reads out one question they will carry into the course. Write the questions on the board and notice which lenses appear most.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- Was it easier to write facts or to write questions? Which lens gave you the most?
- What did your partner's questions make you notice that you had not noticed alone?
- What is one lesson this week where you could spend five minutes on reflection?
Reflect
- When did you last change something in your teaching because of something you noticed, not because someone told you to?
- Which lesson from this month do you keep thinking about, and what is the question inside it?
- Which of the nine lenses do you use least, and what might it show you?
Try it tomorrow
- Choose one lesson this week and write down one critical incident in four or five sentences.
- Pick one lens from courses 5.1 to 5.9 and write one question beginning with 'what', 'when' or 'how many'.
- Put a small notebook in your bag and write five lines after one lesson on Friday.
Further reading and links
Experience becomes learning when you pause, ask a question and choose one change.