Switch course ▾
Session 1. Inclusion and the Barriers Model
Objective. Explain inclusion and the barriers model, describe pupils in respectful non-medical language, and find and remove barriers in a real lesson.
Every class already holds the whole range: the pupil who reads slowly, the one who has just returned from Russia, the one who is bored by ten o'clock. If we treat each as a problem to fix, we run out of time. If we ask what in the lesson is in the way, we find changes that help several pupils at once and cost little. This session gives you a simple way to look, and words that keep every pupil's dignity.
Key ideas
What inclusion means
- Inclusion means every pupil is present, takes part and learns in the ordinary classroom. Sitting in the room is not enough.
- Think of three questions: who is present, who takes part, who is making progress? Any pupil missing from the second or third is a signal.
- In most classes the pupils who need most attention are many: new arrivals, quiet pupils, those who miss school for farm work, and those who find reading hard.
The barriers model
- The deficit view asks 'what is wrong with this pupil?'. The barriers model asks 'what in the lesson makes it hard to take part?'.
- Look for barriers in four places: the task (too long, too abstract), the information (only spoken, tiny print, a language gap), the room (seating, light, noise), and the climate (fear of mistakes, jokes at someone's expense).
- A barrier can be changed by the teacher today. A label cannot.
Respectful, non-medical language
- Teachers observe and describe; they do not diagnose. Say 'finds long texts hard and works well with pictures', not 'he has a disorder'.
- Avoid words that lower a pupil, such as 'weak', 'slow' or 'hopeless', especially in front of the class or in the staff room.
- Write what you saw, when and what helped. Dated notes are useful to parents and school specialists and are fair to the pupil.
Try it in your next lessons
- Action: choose one lesson and run the barrier scan: list barriers in the task, information, room and climate, and remove one barrier at the next lesson.
- Evidence: a 5-minute observation note. Pick two pupils, write down what they did in the first 10 minutes and what you changed, then compare after the change.
- Bring the note to Session 2.
Two ways of looking at the same pupil
Deficit view
- Asks: what is wrong with the pupil?
- Uses labels
- Waits for outside help
Barriers model
- Asks: what is in the way?
- Describes what is seen
- Changes the lesson first
From 'what is wrong with him?' to 'what is in the way?'
The deficit view puts the cause inside the pupil and the answer outside the classroom: a special school, a referral, a lower mark. The barriers model starts with the lesson. Whether a pupil can follow depends on the task, the way information is given, the seating and the climate as much as on the pupil. The same pupil can take full part in a drawing lesson and be lost in a lecture.
This does not mean every difficulty disappears when we change the lesson. Some pupils will still need extra help from specialists. But a teacher who has removed the obvious barriers can describe what remains much more clearly, and that makes any referral far more useful.
Seeing barriers: a five-minute scan
Pick one lesson and walk through it in four columns: task, information, room, climate. Under task ask how long, how abstract and how many steps. Under information ask whether it is only spoken, in small print or in a language some pupils are still learning. Under room ask who sits far from the board or in glare. Under climate ask what happens when someone gives a wrong answer.
Then choose changes that are free, quick and helpful to many: write instructions on the board, move a pupil, give three words before the text, replace 'No, who knows?' with 'Thank you, what could we add?'. One barrier removed this week is worth more than a perfect plan next term.
Examples from the classroom
The board in the glare
Scene. Jasur, Grade 5 in Samarkand, rarely finishes copying from the board and is called slow. A colleague observes for 15 minutes. The afternoon sun glares on the board from his seat, and the teacher wipes each line after two minutes. The teacher moves Jasur two rows over, prints the exercises on half-pages and leaves the text up for five minutes. Jasur finishes 5 of 6 lines the next week.
Insight. The barrier was in the room and the pace, not in the pupil.
The quiet girl
Scene. Malika, Grade 6 in Bukhara, knows the answers but never raises her hand. Her teacher used to say 'No, who knows?' to wrong answers. After the scan, she asks pupils to share answers with a partner first and says 'Thank you, what could we add?'. Within two weeks Malika speaks once or twice per lesson in front of the class.
Insight. A barrier in the climate can silence a pupil who understands.
The returning family
Scene. Sardor, Grade 7 in Tashkent, arrived from Russia last month. His teacher assumed 'he is weak in science'. In a 10-minute observation she sees he understands pictures and numbers well but cannot read the Uzbek key words. She gives him a six-word glossary in Uzbek and Russian. His next exit ticket gets 4 of 5 correct.
Insight. Observe before concluding; the gap was language, not ability.
Common pitfalls
- Using a medical-sounding word for a pupil you have only watched for a few days.
- Treating inclusion as only about pupils with an official disability, and forgetting quiet, absent or newly arrived pupils.
- Blaming yourself for barriers that come from large classes or poor rooms instead of looking for small changes.
- Discussing a pupil's family or health in the staff room.
Barrier Scan of a Lesson Snapshot
- Read the lesson snapshot and six pupil notes in your Activity Kit (Grade 5 Uzbek-medium reading lesson about Navruz). The notes describe what each pupil does, not a label.
- Alone (10 min): fill the barrier scan table. For each pupil write the barrier you think is in the lesson (task, information, room or climate).
- In pairs (15 min): compare, then write one change for each barrier that costs no money and fits in the 45 minutes. Rewrite any note that sounds like a label into respectful words.
- As a group (10 min): choose the three changes with the biggest effect for the most pupils. Say which ones you will try in your own class and how you will record what happened.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- Which barriers helped more than one pupil when removed?
- Which note did you have to rewrite because it sounded like a label? How did the rewrite change your idea of the pupil?
- What is the first barrier you will remove in your own class this week, and what will you write in your observation note?
Reflect
- Which words do you or your colleagues use about pupils that you would not say to their parents?
- Which pupil in your class is present but not really taking part?
- Which barrier in your classroom could you remove today at no cost?
Try it tomorrow
- Run the five-minute scan on tomorrow's lesson and remove one barrier.
- Write one 5-minute observation note about two pupils before and after the change.
- Rewrite one sentence you use about a pupil so it describes what is seen and what helps.
Further reading and links
Ask 'what in the lesson is in the way?', describe pupils respectfully, and remove one barrier at a time.