Switch course ▾
Session 3. Mindset, Effort Praise, Goals and Feedback
Objective. Replace person-praise with process feedback, avoid 'false growth mindset', and help pupils set a clear goal and use a next step.
The words we use after a mark, a mistake or a success teach pupils what ability is. 'You are good at this' and 'you found a better way' sound similar but point to different beliefs. This lesson looks closer at what mindset research does and does not show, how to praise the process without sounding false, and how a clear goal and a single next step make feedback usable. It also helps you handle the practical problem of 35 exercise books on one evening.
Key ideas
Beliefs about ability
- Carol Dweck's work describes a fixed mindset ('I am either good at this or not') and a growth mindset ('my ability can grow with good strategies and effort'). Most people hold a mix, and it changes with the subject and the day.
- Pupils with a fixed view often avoid hard tasks, because failing looks like proof that they are 'not clever'. A growth view makes the same failure a signal to change the strategy.
- Evidence is mixed: large studies find small average effects that are bigger for some groups and schools, so this is a helpful habit, not a miracle.
Praise the process, not the person
- 'You are so clever' tells a pupil that success shows who they are, so failure shows it too. 'You tried two methods and checked your answer' tells them what to repeat.
- Effort praise must be true and specific. Praising effort when the strategy did not work and the pupil knows it sounds like a consolation prize.
- Dweck warns about 'false growth mindset': saying 'just try hard' without teaching new strategies or changing the task. Praise effort together with the strategy and the result.
Goals that guide
- Vague goals ('do your best') guide little. A good goal is specific, a little challenging and checkable: 'solve 8 of 10 equations with correct signs by Friday'.
- Goals about learning ('understand why the sign changes') last longer than goals about beating others ('be first'). Short goals of one to two weeks suit most pupils.
- Let pupils help set the goal. A goal chosen with the pupil is more likely to be pursued than one handed down.
Feedback with three questions
- Hattie and Timperley's model: Where am I going (the goal)? How am I going (progress against the goal)? Where to next (the next step)? Good feedback answers at least the second and the third.
- Feedback works when pupils have time to use it. A comment returned with no chance to act is only a verdict.
- With 35 pupils you cannot comment on everything. Choose one criterion, one comment per paper, and give class time (5 minutes) to act on it.
The feedback loop
Mindset: useful idea, limited claim
Mindset ideas are popular, so it matters to use them accurately. Large studies suggest that short programmes teaching that ability can grow have small average effects on grades, larger for lower-achieving pupils and in schools where classmates and teachers support the idea. Dweck herself warns that mindsets are mixed and that simply praising effort can turn into a 'false growth mindset'.
The classroom message is modest and practical. Do not label pupils. Show, through tasks and comments, that struggle is expected, that strategies can be learnt and that a mistake tells you what to try next. Teachers' own talk matters: 'I am bad at this' from the front of the room teaches a fixed view.
Feedback that gets used
Feedback helps when it closes a gap between where the pupil is and the goal, and when the pupil acts on it. Comments on the person ('careless') or on a mark alone carry little to act on. Comments on the task ('the units are missing in lines 2 and 4') or the strategy ('draw the table first') are more useful. Pupils also need time: five minutes in class to redo one line is worth more than a long comment read on the way out.
Save your time by choosing one criterion for a set of papers, writing one comment per paper, and sorting papers into three piles by the most common error. Then teach the pile's mini-lesson to the whole group. Praise correct work too: it tells pupils which strategies to keep.
Examples from the classroom
Praise with a strategy
Scene. Malika teaches Grade 8 algebra in Tashkent. Instead of 'well done, you are good at algebra', she writes on Aziz's page: 'You checked the answer by substituting and found your sign error. Try that on the last two as well.' Aziz does. At the next lesson three other pupils copy the habit because she read his method aloud, with his permission, as a strategy.
Insight. Naming the strategy gives the pupil and the class something to repeat.
Five minutes to act
Scene. Dilnoza has 34 Grade 7 essays on 'My mahalla'. She chooses one criterion, a detail in every sentence, writes one comment each and sorts papers into three piles. At the start of the next lesson pupils get 5 minutes to add two details. She counts: 21 of 34 pupils improved at least one sentence. She keeps three examples and plans a mini-lesson for the others.
Insight. One criterion, one comment and class time to act make feedback manageable and used.
A goal chosen together
Scene. In a school near Samarkand, Jasur says to Bobur, 'Which skill do you want to be better at by Friday?'. Bobur picks 'reading the clock in minutes'. They agree he will read 8 of 10 clocks correctly. On Friday he reads 7. Jasur says, 'You went from 4 to 7. Your next step is the quarter hours.' Bobur asks to try the clocks again on Monday.
Insight. A specific goal chosen with the pupil makes progress visible and the next step natural.
Common pitfalls
- Praising effort when the strategy clearly failed and the pupil knows it.
- Writing long comments that nobody has time to act on.
- Using the same words ('well done') for every pupil, so they carry no information.
- Talking about your own weakness as fixed ('I was never good at maths') in front of pupils.
Rewrite the Comment
- Open the Activity Kit: ten teacher comments (SAMPLES) on pupils' work and a goal-and-feedback card.
- Pairs (12 min): mark each comment as person-praise, empty praise, process feedback or a verdict with no next step. Then rewrite five of them so that they name the strategy or effort and give one next step.
- Pairs (10 min): take the sample pupil's work (Grade 7 paragraph) and write a goal with the pupil in one sentence, then a feedback comment that answers 'how am I going' and 'where to next'.
- Groups (8 min): agree how you will keep feedback to 5 minutes per pile in a class of 35, and where in the lesson pupils will act on it.
- Alone (5 min): write your classroom action task from the Kit.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- Which of your usual comments are person-praise? What would you say instead?
- When is 'try harder' not enough? What would the pupil need instead?
- How can feedback be useful if there are only 5 minutes in the lesson to act on it?
Reflect
- What did your teachers say that you still remember about your ability?
- Do you ever say 'I am bad at this' about yourself in front of pupils?
- Which one criterion would give the most useful comments on your next set of papers?
Try it tomorrow
- Rewrite three of your usual comments so that each names what the pupil did and gives one next step.
- Mark one set with a single criterion and give 5 minutes of lesson time to act on the comments.
- With two pupils, agree a one-sentence goal for Friday and check it together.
Further reading and links
Praise what the pupil did, not what they are; set a clear goal; give one next step and time to use it.