Switch course ▾
Session 4. Rewards, Pressure and the Adolescent Student
Objective. Judge a reward system as informational or controlling, redesign one, and adapt motivation support to the needs of adolescents.
Stickers, stars, rankings and prizes are everywhere in schools, usually with good intentions. Research on rewards is more careful than slogans on either side: some rewards hurt, others help, and the difference lies in how pupils experience them. Adolescents add a second challenge, because at 12 to 16 the opinion of peers and the feeling of being respected matter very much. This lesson helps you audit your own habits and keep recognition that informs rather than controls.
Key ideas
Rewards are not all the same
- A reward can carry information ('you reached the goal') or control ('do this and you get that'). The pupil's feeling of choice is what changes the effect.
- Deci, Koestner and Ryan reviewed many experiments. Expected tangible rewards for an activity people already enjoyed tended to lower later interest in it; unexpected rewards did not. Verbal praise that gave information tended to help.
- The research does not say 'never reward'. It says: be careful when the activity is already interesting, and beware of rewards that feel like bribes.
Reward systems to examine
- Common school systems: stars and stickers, public rankings, marks for homework completion, prizes for 'best class', and little treats. Ask of each: does it tell pupils something useful, or just push them?
- Public ranking often helps the top 3 and hurts the rest, who learn their place. It rewards being better than others rather than getting better.
- Marks used as threats ('I will lower your mark') raise short-term compliance but teach pupils to work only when watched.
Making recognition informational
- Recognise specific progress and effort that pupils can repeat: 'You went from 4 to 7 correct in three weeks', 'The class kept to the plan during group work'.
- Use rewards for boring tasks that are simply necessary (tidying the room), but give a reason and keep them small. For tasks pupils already like, prefer recognition over prizes.
- Never remove a long-standing reward suddenly without explaining; if you plan to end a sticker system, taper it and replace it with a goal.
The adolescent: belonging, identity, fairness
- Between about 12 and 16 pupils care more about peers, about being respected, and about fairness. A teacher who shames a pupil in front of classmates loses more than one lesson.
- Studies of adolescents report that perceived support for competence and a classroom that gives some independence go with better effort; school and class matter a lot. Be wary of simple stories that all teenagers 'lose motivation'.
- Give older pupils more voice: a say in how to practise, respect for their opinions, private feedback, and tasks with real purpose (a class survey about the mahalla, a presentation for Grade 5).
Informational or controlling recognition
Informational
Tells me how I am doing
- Specific: what and how
- Based on my own progress
- Surprise or private
Controlling
Pushes me to comply
- Vague: 'good', a star
- Based on rank or threat
- Expected, public, compared
What the reward research actually says
A large review of experiments found that expected tangible rewards given for doing an activity tended to reduce later interest in it, especially for children and for activities they already liked. Unexpected rewards did not have this effect, and verbal praise that told people something about their performance tended to help. The review does not say that all rewards are bad; it says that the way the reward is framed matters.
The pattern is easy to understand. When a reward becomes the reason for the activity, the pupil's own reason can fade. When recognition says 'here is what you did well', the pupil keeps ownership. Also remember that most studies were done outside Uzbekistan, so test locally rather than assume.
Adolescents: respect, voice, peers
Adolescents notice unfairness quickly and dislike being treated as small children. Public comments, rankings read aloud and sarcasm cost a teacher more than they gain. Studies of pupils in Grades 7 to 10 find that perceived support for competence goes with better effort, and that classroom design matters; but they also warn against simple stories in which all teenagers lose motivation.
Practical respect is simple. Speak privately about problems. Give a real role: explain a topic to Grade 5, run a class survey about the mahalla, choose between two ways of practising. Allow some independence in how work is done, but keep the aim and the standard clear. Peers are an ally: group tasks with clear roles help many pupils feel they belong.
Examples from the classroom
From ranking to progress
Scene. Nodira teaches Grade 8 Russian in Namangan. The school ranks pupils monthly, so she adds a class list called 'Who moved, and how'. She names three pupils who improved from their own starting point and what each did: 'Sevara practised 5 verbs every day'. She reads no ranking aloud. After three weeks, more pupils volunteer, and Sevara asks for a harder set of verbs.
Insight. Recognising progress from the pupil's own start keeps recognition informational inside a school rule.
The sweets for maps
Scene. Jasur gives a sweet for every map that Grade 6 pupils draw in free time. After two weeks, fewer pupils draw at break. He stops the sweets and instead hangs the maps on the wall with a note saying what each shows. A month later, three pupils bring maps of their own mahalla without being asked.
Insight. Replacing an expected prize with specific recognition protects interest that already exists.
A task for the older pupils
Scene. Grade 9 in Fergana finds a worksheet on ratios dull. Dilnoza asks pupils to survey 20 neighbours about bazaar prices and prepare a 5-minute talk for Grade 5. Pupils choose their topic: onions, bread or apricots. Attendance on the survey day is full, and several pupils ask to use the same method for a geography project.
Insight. Adolescents respond to real purpose, a real audience and some choice.
Common pitfalls
- Removing a long-standing reward suddenly with no explanation.
- Reading rankings or marks aloud to the class.
- Giving a prize for a task pupils already enjoy.
- Treating all adolescents as one group: a quiet 15-year-old and a loud 15-year-old need different things.
Reward Audit and Redesign
- Open the Activity Kit: six reward systems used in schools (SAMPLES) and two adolescent scenes.
- Pairs (12 min): for each system answer four questions: Is it expected or a surprise? Is the activity already interesting? Does it tell pupils something useful? Who wins and who loses? Mark it INFORMATIONAL, CONTROLLING or MIXED.
- Pairs (10 min): redesign the two worst systems with a minimum change. Keep what is good (the aim), change what is controlling (the way).
- Groups (8 min): read the two adolescent scenes and agree on a response for the next lesson. Say what you will not do.
- Alone (5 min): write your classroom action task from the Kit.
Your facilitator will guide you through this activity in the session.
Questions to discuss
- Which reward system in your school is most controlling? What does it teach pupils about why they study?
- What is the smallest change that would make it informational?
- What do 14-year-olds in your school need that 9-year-olds do not?
Reflect
- Which pupil in your class works only for a mark or a prize? What might happen if you stopped giving it?
- When did a teacher's public comment hurt your motivation as a teenager?
- Where in your teaching do older pupils already have a real voice?
Try it tomorrow
- Audit one reward habit with four questions: expected, already interesting, informative, who loses.
- Replace one public comparison with a list of who improved and how.
- Give older pupils one real role or choice in the next week.
Further reading and links
Reward information, not obedience; protect interest that already exists; give adolescents respect and a voice.